It addresses and answers virtually all of the difficult questions that are on the minds of traditional catholics, and even the conservative catholics, today. Sedevacantist sedevacantist protest against the report posted by tia that pope pius ix was formerly a mason. We must not tempt god by taking extraordinary actions unless absolutely necessary. Is this the sacred action that was necessary for the continuation of the priesthood and of apostolic succession.
Recently, father anthony cekada released a video entitled why traditionalists fear sedevacantism. Answering the objections to the sedevacantist position compiled by bishop mark a. Sedevacantism is the position, held by a small group of traditionalist catholics, that the person in the papal see right now is not truly pope and that, for lack of a good pope, the see has been empty since the death of pope pius xii in 1958. It is a grave danger for those who are well educated in catholic dogma and theology and are trying to be faithful to traditional catholic teaching a practices find inconsistencies with how the catholic faith was taught before and how it is taught and practiced today. Tradition in action bookstore catholic books, booklets. If these well known traditionalists worked stunning miracles or even some small wonders it is fair to believe that the whole of the traditional world would be alerted to the fact very quickly. Sedevacantism and the sedevacantist thesis proved by. We reject the anti popes and regard them as anti christs.
Pope pius xii lifted all ecclesiastical penalties during the conclave to elect the pope. In our first article in this series, we examined how the principles of sedevacantism require us to divide the person of the pope from the petrine unity that inheres in the popes office. Sedevacantism has only one difficulty which is the restoration of a true claimant to the chair of peter. Why vatican iis clash with sedevacantism supports eastern orthodoxy pontrello, john c. Sedevacantism is the theological position of those traditional catholics who most certainly believe in the papacy, papal infallibility and the primacy of the roman pontiff, and yet do not recognize pope francis edit.
Sedevacantism, sedevacantist and sede vacante explained. For this reason my book was strictly a study on sedevacantism but i could have written a more comprehensive book and titled it the traditional catholic delusion. In the meantime, we recommend you check out the following. What are we to think of the sedevacantist position. Sedevacantism is a theological position held by traditional catholics who recognize the novus ordo church as a noncatholic modernist religion, officially brought into being at the second vatican council 19621965 and the leaders of that sect to be antipopes, leaving the seat of st. This is a stepbystep consideration and refutation of the little book by fr.
He then goes on to answer objections to sedevacantism, speaking about opinionism and finally the unacummass. For some questions, the practical course of action. So even if the vatican ii popes were heretics before their. Sedevacantism the following articles are copied from our blog in february 2011. Peter as first pope when he was given authority by jesus to rule the church. They believe that because the popes since pope john xxiii have expressed opinions that may appear to be.
Sedevacantist and traditional catholics who stay with the. Resisting the pope, sedevacantism and frankenchurch 2005 by rev. The sedevacantist delusion concerns the new face of roman catholicism introduced with vatican ii 19621965 and its most antagonistic enemy since the protestant reformers. Their priests respond like they are brain dead, and either have no answer at all or tell me to read the salzasiscoe book. Due to the crisis in the church and the papal scandals that. We are here to affirm traditional catholicism based on the bible, church tradition and all of the legitimate and true councils of the church. Divine mercy is a false devotion, promoted by the wicked antipope jp ii, the one who proclaims that islam is an unconventional way of salvation redemptoris missio no56 and that every man is god dont remember where. We aim to provide a variety of sedevacantist links here for your consideration. Sedevacantism is not against reason or catholicism, its simply in the realm of mystery. First it is highly useful to those who might be tempted by sedevacantism, in order to enable them to reject it right away for its many flaws. Tia also works for a restoration of christian civilization, adapted to contemporary historical circumstances. I think traditional catholicism can sometimes attract poor people like this because the necessity of even having to use the term traditional catholicism is a reflection of the fact that somethings gone seriously wrong in the human element of the church, and that something was warned about by our popes since the socalled englightenment. Jun 19, 2018 chazal has packed his book contra cekadam with catholic theology, sanity, and common sense, attacking some of the common errors of sedevacantism, especially those of the more extreme and dogmatic. Explosion of hatred from sedevacantists tradition in action.
Nov 03, 2019 lay sspxers agree with my arguments up to a point. If you want to read a book that traces the history of the church and effectively puts the. With women active in the catholic action movement, he founded a contemplative religious community called the oasis, near barcelona. The church of jesus christ divine physician sedevacantism. The sedevacantist delusion why vatican iis clash with sedevacantism supports eastern orthodoxy is a book by john pontrello that refutes sedevacantism. Answering the objections to the sedevacantist position.
It is of great interest to many people to know what was the late, great archbishop lefebvres attitude to the thesis that paul vi andjohn paul ii were not true popes. This is because any miracle that they worked would be a confirmation of the sedevacantist or sedeprivationist doctrines that they taught. Sedevacantism the vacancy of the papal throne since the death of pope pius xii the chair of st. You can also use software like calibre ebook management its free to manage all of your e book and convert them into the format that you prefer. Refuting sedevacantism and other modern errors, by john salza and robert siscoe, 700 pages true or false pope.
Siscoes book will surely afford much clarity to the reader. Argument speray refutes salzasiscoe argument from canon 10 of constantinople iv pdf. Here is a standard passage from a prevatican ii manual that of fr. Mar 27, 2015 sedevacantism comes from the latin sede vacante, which means seat vacant. Refuting sedevacantism and other modern errors foreword by his excellency bernard fellay a cfn interview with john salza and robert siscoe release date december 2015. Since the 1980s, there has been a steady, if slow, movement among those who have been supporters of the sspx into sedevacantism. You can purchase online with your credit card using paypal select each item you want and click on the add to cart button. Fr chazal book contra cekadam against sedevacantism youtube. Sedevacantism is the position, held by some catholics, that the present occupier of the holy see is not truly pope due to the mainstream churchs espousal of what they see as the heresy of modernism and that, for lack of a valid pope, the see has been vacant since the death of pope pius xii in 1958. We reject the council of apostasy known as vatican ii. I would appreciate your comments about your position, and the position visavis the papacy. A refutation of the heresy of sedevacantism freeyellow.
Refuting sedevacantism and other modern errors by john salza. Sedevacantists and una cum masses most holy trinity seminary. It is the position held by a small portion of traditional catholics who claim that the papal seat, the holy see, has been vacant since around 1960. Sedevacantism comes from the latin sede vacante, which means seat vacant. Ratzingers frankenchurch heresy that denies an article of the creed. We have read this affirmation in many books written by good historians. Written in preparation for a talk on sedevacantism, available from our bookstore on cd or mp3 i. The tia logo pictures the statue of the emperor charlemagne with his knights roland and olivier. We may place here an alternative method of recommending books in the future but for the time being, our virtual book store is discontinued. Here are some questions that nonsedevacantist defenders of the vatican ii church need to consider. Due to the recent publication of the book true or false pope. The book was originally intended to be a refutation of sedevacantism alone, but it developed into much more.
Sedevacantist devoted to true catholicism, rejecting. And while during an interregnum the church is popeless, for a short period of time, this is not a part of the ordinary constitution of the church and must necessarily be of short duration. My expert traditional roman catholic friend said this book will save me from. Tradition in action depicts the magnificent statue of charlemagne. Secondly it is of great help for all catholics in general, to help them understand better the present crisis of the church, and the true traditional position. The difficulty of tackling sedevacantism is that sedevacantist ideas are generally developing into different areas, or as a friend of mine has mentioned, they are upping the ante. Why vatican iis clash with traditional catholicism supports eastern orthodoxy and my conclusions would be the same. Sedevacantism and the sedevacantist thesis proved by antipope. Why vatican iis clash with sedevacantism supports eastern orthodoxy, by john c. More books will be added periodically time is allowed.
True or false pope refuting sedevacantism and other. Shawn mcelhinney the visibility of the church is directly linked to the roman pontiff. Traditional catholic book store in october 2017, discontinued the storefront application we were using to recommend books of interest to traditional catholics. Feb 24, 2010 here are some questions that nonsedevacantist defenders of the vatican ii church need to consider. We do not endorse any particular group nor do we necessarily agree with all of the views expressed on any of the following sites. A little catechism on sedevacantism what is sedevacantism.
Daily issue of the dailycatholic, a traditional catholic publication dedicated to. We resist you to your face pdf, traditional mass, p. They also believe that sedevacantism is a fundamental error and claim sedevacantists believe a pope can do no wrong. Although there is no such book in which all things are defined and set out we may thank god it doesnt as it would not be enough, as there would be the issue of how to interpret it. Fr chazal book contra cekadam against sedevacantism. Jun, 2005 the popes and the modern crisis on sedevacantism jun, 2005 brother andre marie brother andre marie you need to register to be part of that conference on christ the king tomorrow. Sep 15, 2017 refuting sedevacantism and other modern errors. It is the position held by traditional catholics who claim that the papal seat, the holy see, has been vacant since the death of pope pius xii in 1958. Traditional catholic books for sale here, written and published by tradition in action. For those inclined to investigate further, here are links to articles that provide a deeper explanation of the foregoing argument, together with citations to the writings of popes, theologians, canon law experts, and saints whose writings provide the unassailable basis for the sedevacantist argument in catholic teaching. International independent traditional catholic megachurch organization. Thats right, they claim we should follow those who formally severed communion with nestorius before the church rendered her judgment, instead of the example of cyril of alexandria even though cyril is a saint and doctor of the church, and even though the action taken by the former those who severed communion by private judgment has been. He put forward sedevacantist ideas in his books the new montinian church. Archbishop lefebvre and the sedevacantist thesis liberty, courage, and prudence.
Secondly it is of great help for all catholics in general. Sedevacantism simple english wikipedia, the free encyclopedia. We can send you a free packet containing information about the traditional mass, the vatican ii changes and the traditionalist movement. Sedevacantism is the position, held by some catholics, that the present occupier of the holy see is not truly pope due to the mainstream churchs espousal of what they see as the heresy of modernism and that, for lack of a valid pope, the see has been vacant since the death of pope pius xii in 1958 the term sedevacantism is derived from the latin phrase sede vacante. Why vatican iis clash with sedevacantism supports eastern orthodoxy. Peter who is regarded by catholics as the first bishop of. Concerning an sspx dossier on sedevacantism novus ordo watch. The religion of abandonment sedevacantism and the heresy of conciliarism. The video is a response to the soontobereleased book by john salza and robert siscoe, true or false pope. Sedevacantism is the position, held by some catholics, that the present occupier of the holy. Some, like the dimond brothers, have embraced a heretical feeneyism, while declaring other sedevacantists, such as cekadas enterprise, as heretical. Recently, though, a layman who is a respected major player in the sspx empire invited me over to talk with him about sedevacantism. The simple answer often proffered inanswer to this question is that the archbishop was not.
Tradition in action is committed to defend the perennial magisterium of holy mother church and catholic traditions. Felix sarda y salvany in his book liberalism is a sin this has to. Refutation of sedevacantism dominicans of avrille, france. On this page we present a slew of links to articles, blog posts, books, audios, and videos dealing with the subject matter of the papacy, sedevacantism, the false theological position known as recognizebutresist. Apart, but related to that, the tome is useful as the theological manual of ecclesiology that it is.
The special mission of this community is to pray for priests. The method to obtain this publication the sedevacantist delusion. Why traditionalists are not afraid of sedevacantism. A tiny number of these people claim the vacancy actually goes back to the death of pope pius x in 1914, among other littleknown positions. Father gruner and his associate christopher ferrara have presumed to inform the faithful that sedevacantism is not a legitimate position for catholics to take and that indeed all catholics must accept the postconciliar popes as. With all the confusion in the church today, you can sympathize with sedevacantist. Resisting the pope, sedevacantism and frankenchurch. You might not go for some places and invest the moment to only. Refuting sedevacantism and other modern errors by john salza 20150802 john salza. Chazal has packed his book contra cekadam with catholic theology, sanity, and common sense, attacking some of the common errors of sedevacantism, especially those of the more extreme and dogmatic. True or false pope refuting sedevacantism and other modern.
1076 2 1205 1257 144 431 704 564 1500 786 770 1058 1401 743 514 188 486 656 1452 767 261 394 820 1287 445 84 311 507 1085 374 1147 354 395 1439 1305